Reject reviewer comments
WebSep 30, 2014 · Related Infographic. 8 Reasons why journals reject manuscripts. Rejection is the norm in scientific publishing. But by…. 7.7k. Such errors can make the peer reviewers … WebMost journals give reviewers the option to provide some confidential comments to editors. Often this is where editors will want reviewers to state their recommendation - see the …
Reject reviewer comments
Did you know?
WebAug 9, 2024 · You can choose to appeal against the editorial decision. Since reviewer comments are in your favor, you might be able to build a compelling case. However, be aware that most of the time, appeals are not successful and might lead to further waste of time. So, if you are running short of time, it might be better to submit your paper to … WebAug 31, 2024 · Recently I received a rejection letter from a journal editor (including some comments). However, when I checked the reviewers comments (from two reviewers), I …
WebMoreover, an example of cover letter that can go with your response to reviewers' comments is provided. Discover the world's research. 20+ million members; 135+ million publication pages; WebThe reject review(s) are weak while the accept review(s) are strong. I once had a paper were one reviewer said "this paper is clearly wrong, if we accept this methodology one can prove anything, reject" without elaborating. The paper also had three other reviewers who all took the paper seriously and gave suggestions for improvements.
WebComments to Editors and Authors. The editor not only uses reviewer comments to help make a decision. They will often refer to them in their decision letter. With this in mind, it’s helpful to editors if you: Number your comments. Are clear about which points are absolutely critical if the paper is given an opportunity for revision. WebThe decision depends on the editor's judgment of the quality of the article given the quality and policy of the journal. Some quality journals reject an article even when two or more …
WebSep 11, 2024 · Replied on September 11, 2024. Report abuse. You can choose to display revisions from a specific reviewer, via Review > Show Markup > Specific People, and then accept all revisions shown, by clicking Review > Accept > Accept All Changes Shown. EDIT: Review > Reject > Reject All Changes Shown. Stefan Blom.
WebIf the editor sent specific instructions for the reviewer report, or a form to fill out as part of the review, you should write your report in the requested format. ... or to reject the paper. … high risk investmentsWebSep 27, 2013 · In the case where more than one referee has raised the same concern, it’s best to cite “see response to point 2 from Reviewer #1”, for example. Do remember that each reviewer sees all comments and your replies so be equally respectful to all. The DON’Ts: Don’t vent or accuse the reviewers of bias or incompetence. how many calories of fat per gramWebOct 17, 2013 · Don’ts. Don’t argue every single comment. If the reviewer has suggested a minor revision that you might not entirely agree with, but is easy to comply with and does not take away any value from your study, it might be easier to incorporate it that to argue your case. Do not take a negative comment from the reviewer as a personal attack. high risk investments 2017WebJul 30, 2024 · The core problem is that I am worried that, after resubmission, the editors might decide "reject" for my paper, based upon the non-sense comments of Reviewer #2. That would be terrible to me. I am considering to write an email to the editor and ask him politely to ignore the unprofessional indications of Reviewer #2, and why. high risk investments 2019WebOct 7, 2024 · The standard Terms are 'Reject Pre Review and Suggest Transfer' and 'Reject Post Review and Suggest Transfer' but journals can customize. The main difference is in the wording of the decision letter, 'Pre-Review' does not mention reviewer comments. Complete the decision form as described in How do I make a decision in Editorial Manager? high risk investments 2020WebReason 1: The suggested change would require you to conduct new research. Example reviewer's comment: "Your results are interesting, but I'd like to know what would happen if you had studied the effect on adolescents, in addition to adults." Phrases you can use: "follow-up study," "future research/consideration," "new direction," "outside the ... high risk investments 2023WebStay calm. Ask your supervisor or a colleague to look over the reviewer comments to see what they think. It will help you to determine whether your assessment of the review is correct. Email the editor and explain your challenge with the reviewer’s comments. Don’t let your emotions get the best of you. high risk investments examples